Thursday, September 30, 2010

5D Sound Solution by Mark Messenger at

5D Sound Solution by  Mark Messenger at

5D Sound SolutionThe Canon 5D and other members of the Canon DSLR camera family are getting out on video shoots more and more, thanks to their image making qualities. But this creates a problem for audio. Recording through the mini jack microphone input to tracks that will be compressed on the whim of the camera is hardly going to create audio of a quality I would like to put my name to.
I recently landed a job, only to be told it was to be shot on the Canon 5D.
At first I wasn’t concerned. My thoughts were to simply treat it like a film camera and slate everything. But I was told the job was a behind the scenes, observational style documentary. Using a slate every time we rolled just wasn’t going to be practical.
Some form of double system recording was needed – without a slate. That’s when I began my search for a solution that allowed us to button on and off frequently, and at the same time provide something that the post-production guys could deal with efficiently.
Efficiency was very important – we were planning on providing 50 plus clips per day. This would require good metadata on each clip, so that the editors could quickly identify each one and marry it up to its corresponding sound.
It was clear that some sort of batch auto sync system would be ideal because it would mean the editors didn’t have to spend a lot time and money syncing each clip individually.

5d connections
Connected for Sound
The easiest way to do that was to have identical time-of-day time code on each clip and corresponding sound file. But the Canon 5D doesn’t have a time code generator or time code input. This meant that the time code would have to come from the sound recorder.
This eliminated the Zoom H4 sound recorder and Sound Devices 552 mixer combination because an external time code source would be required. I wasn’t sorry because I had tested the Zoom recorder and found it very limited and lacking in functionality with quite a few traps – it’s a fairly crap recorder if you want to use it as professionally.
As well as that, the 552 mixer doesn’t seem to have metadata input and just increments each file number as 1,2,3,4…. etc. The chances were high that audio files would be given the same name across card changes and different days. This could confuse the editors and waste time in post – especially if there was more than one crew working on the same day.
After some thought we came up with another idea: to use Echo Digital Audio sync software. But this presented potential problems too. Again you would have to sync up each clip individually, and it appeared you needed to separately to press both camera and sound on and off button at nearly the same time.
The next idea was to use a fairly unknown technique of sending time code from the sound recorder and putting it down on the audio track of the clip within the camera. When the editors get hold of the clip they can use the “read audio time code” function in the “special” menu of Avid. They then use this time code as a sync reference for the separately recorded audio track.
getting it right
Connectors into the 5D
I found that I had to pad it back quite a lot as the time code comes out a roughly line level and the 5D input is at mic level. If you sent it in too hot then there was a good chance that it might distort the time code making it hard for the Avid to read.
We did some tests and got the editors up to speed (something that you need to do before starting to shoot).
It worked great. The editors seemed to love it as it meant they did not have to waste time syncing each individual clip, they could batch auto sync saving the production money.
Mark Messenger is an Auckland film and television sound recordist.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Canon 4K Concept Camera

One of the most interesting things was the Canon 4k concept camera and 4k monitor! It’s only 2/3rd inch but it’s still interesting and a sign of where they are going? I must emphasise this camera will never come out. It’s a concept camera showing the technology. Are they planning to take on RED? No idea but it will be interesting to see where this path will take us…it’s no Epic that is for sure…which is real and being tested out in the field…how long though before Canon bring something like this out for real? Ideally for me in an APS-C minimum sized chip but I talk more about this further down the post. The 4K monitor was great as you can imagine, 32″ and sharp as hell. It’s one of those things of course that you need to see in person…
I was actually the first one in...
I REALLY like the XF 105. It’s tiny and has amazing specs. 422 50mbs hd sdi and genlock. The XF 100 is the same but without the SDI/ Genlock. Both record onto CF cards. I guess it is a direct competitor to the JVC 100. Size wise it looks identical, almost…but spec wise it is simply really impressive. It’s the first camcorder in recent memory that I have actually wanted. It has all the facial tracking auto focus that the Vixia has but in a much much better cameras.
XF 105 3D rig
As you can see, it's tiny.
This is the Canon 4K concept camera.It was actually working and was crisp as hell…This concept camera had  a fixed 2/3″ 20x Zoom lens as the chip itself is 2/3″. I am not sure what the idea of it is, they mentioned something about medical something or other. It’s obviously not a cinema concept camera due to the fixed lens. The image out of it was actually really really nice. As I have said and I and am sure you all want to,  is to see an APS-C chip in camera like this and use all the current Canon glass or PL lenses…but Canon have a different marketing strategy to someone like RED. RED announce their road map and make it very public. Canon keep things close to their chest. If there is a cinema camera coming out or a new improved DSLR for video there is no way they would show a concept camera of it and show the competition what they have up their sleeve. Canon do not give much away and of course that is probably from a business stand point the best thing to do. That is why this camera really is to show what they are capable of more than anything, not what they plan to do…I would put money down that we won’t know until pretty close to release of any big developments with regards to video in DSLR or the next evolution of that.
There was also no word of any firmware or other lenses, they were all announced last week. I expect the much rumoured and much expected 1DSmkiV will make it’s debut at Photokina in Cologne later this month. I will be watching this very closely as it MAY have improved video functions, again, pure speculation but I can be positive and hope can’t i?

planet5D-Canon HDSLR news (5Dmk2, 7D, 1Dmk4)

HD Mag

Independent Short Films


The Big Idea - What's On & Reviews RSS feed

Sean O'Connor's An Actor's Life For Me!

CREWS.TV - TV Freelance Network

M2 Entertainment

Reviews (latest): Digital Photography Review (

Philip Bloom

Vincent Laforet's Blog

The blog of Editorial Photographer Zack Arias

The Art of the Title Sequence

Recent activities from Saltee at MySpace